At the Chincoteague Pony Penning auction on July 30, 2026, 74 take-home foals sold for an average of $5,378, from $3,000 to $10,500, according to the results printed by the International Chincoteague Pony Association & Registry. One South Carolina seller asks $5,000 to $35,000 on its sale page as of November 18, 2026, and rescues post pony adoption fees from waived to $500. These are one auction, one seller and a few rescues, not a national price.
What ponies sold for: the Chincoteague auction
The foals are wild-born, and the auction is run by the Chincoteague Volunteer Fire Company. The registry printed the take-home results for 2024, 2025 and 2026 in the same form.
| Year | Foals sold | Average | High | Low | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 (July 30) | 74 | $5,378 | $10,500 | $3,000 | $398,000 |
| 2025 | 88 | $7,416 | $50,000 | $3,000 | $652,600 |
| 2024 | 81 | $3,795 | $8,500 | $1,600 | $307,400 |
Source: International Chincoteague Pony Association & Registry: 2026 results; 2025 results; 2024 results, checked November 18, 2026.
The registry marked the 2025 high, average and total as new records; the 2026 average was 27 % lower ($5,378 ÷ $7,416 = 0.73).
The 2026 page also prints overall totals: a high bid of $60,000, an average of $7,842 and $635,200 in all. Those include 7 buybacks, which buy naming rights while the foal stays with the Fire Company, so they are not purchase prices. The overall line says 94 foals sold, but $635,200 ÷ $7,842 = 81, which matches 74 take-home foals plus 7 buybacks.
Asking prices from a seller and a sale
Elhanan Equestrian in Hodges, South Carolina, prices 11 ponies, one of them a foal not yet born, from $5,000 to $35,000. The table shows six of them. They are asking prices, not sale prices.
| Pony | Age and height as listed | Asking price |
|---|---|---|
| Big Bears Glory Be, purebred Connemara mare, broodmare or riding pony | Born 2009, 14.2 hands | $5,000 |
| Doodlebug, grade appaloosa pony gelding | 12.1 hands | $7,500 |
| Elhanan’s Celtic Moon, purebred Connemara filly | Born 2022, 15 hands | $10,500 |
| Lady Chalotte, German Riding Pony mare, unstarted | 3 years old | $12,000 |
| Una Chanel, German Riding Pony mare, unstarted | Born 2022, 14.3 hands | $12,500 |
| TBF Sweet Deliverance “Piper”, purebred Connemara mare | Born 2017, 14 hands | $35,000 |
Source: Elhanan Equestrian: Sales, checked November 18, 2026.
The seller ties price to training: Piper’s $35,000 is “subject to change with miles”, and Doodlebug’s price will increase with training and show miles, per the listing. The two unstarted young mares ask $12,000 and $12,500; the 2017 mare asks almost three times as much ($35,000 ÷ $12,000 = 2.9).
At the 2025 SoCal Premier Horse Sale in California, the high-selling pony, Mario, a 2019 gelding of 12.3 hands, sold for $50,000, and the reserve high seller, Woodchuck, a 2016 Quarter Pony gelding of 13 hands, for $15,000. Each is one lot, not an average.
Source: Premier Horse Sales: 2025 SoCal results, checked November 18, 2026.
Adoption fees at rescues
East Tennessee Miniature Horse and Donkey Rescue lists a typical adoption fee of $500 for ponies over 40 inches on its adoption page; its FAQ page prints $250, reduced for pairs. Horses Haven in Howell, Michigan, lists these pony fees:
- Blaze, a 2017 Shetland gelding of about 11.1 hands: $500
- Rosie, a 15-year-old pony cross mare: $350
- Candy, a pony mare born around 2001: fee waived, companion adoption
- Tango, a Draft and Welsh Pony cross gelding of 13.2 hands: $350
- OnStar and Chris, a pair of Hackney geldings of 12.0 hands: $350
Source: East Tennessee Miniature Horse and Donkey Rescue: Adoption; FAQs; Horses Haven: Ponies and Minis, checked November 18, 2026.
Registration and transfer fees
The American Shetland Pony Club’s work order, revised December 1, 2025, covers its four registries and makes membership mandatory for all registry work. The American Connemara Pony Society’s undated fee page lists member fees, doubled for non-members.
| Registry and item | Fee |
|---|---|
| ASPC transfer of ownership, less than 12 months after sale | $25 |
| ASPC late transfer, more than 12 months after sale | $50 |
| ASPC registration, weanling | $30 (to 6 months); $35 (to Dec 31) |
| ASPC registration, yearling | $45 |
| ASPC US membership, expires December 31 | $85 a year |
| ACPS registration within 6 months of foaling, member | $125 |
Source: American Shetland Pony Club: Customer Work Order; American Connemara Pony Society: Registration, checked November 18, 2026.
A buyer transferring a Shetland within a year pays $110 with membership ($25 + $85), or $113.30 if paid by card with the 3 % processing fee ($110 × 1.03). The ACPS fee includes a DNA test, microchip and USEF lifetime number; for a non-member it is $250 ($125 × 2).
What counts as a pony
Virginia Cooperative Extension’s 4-H guide measures horses at the withers in hands of 4 inches and draws the line here:
“Ponies - A smaller horse. Has to be 14.2 hands or under.”
Source: Virginia Cooperative Extension, Publication 4H-308, checked November 18, 2026.
14.2 hands is 58 inches (14 × 4 + 2). Show divisions and registries set their own limits: US Equestrian’s measurement guide splits hunter ponies into small (not over 12.2 hands), medium (to 13.2) and large (to 14.2), and caps Welsh Section A at 12.2 hands, Section B at 14.2 and Section C, the cob type, at 13.2, with no upper limit for the Section D cob.
Oklahoma State University’s breed pages put the Connemara at 12.2 to 14.2 hands and the Shetland at an average of 9.3 hands, not exceeding 10.2. The 15-hand Connemara filly above stands over both lines.
Source: US Equestrian: Measurement Guide; Oklahoma State University: Connemara Pony; Shetland Pony, checked November 18, 2026.
UK pony sales, in guineas and pounds
British sales print results in guineas or pounds; they are not US prices.
| Sale | Date | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Lerwick Shetland Pony Sale, Shetland Islands | October 9, 2025 | 67 sold, average 709 gns; top 2600 guineas, twice |
| Shetland Pony Stud Book Society Autumn Sale, Worcester | October 26, 2025 | Top 7,200 gns (five-year-old mare); colt foals to 1,800 gns, filly foals to 6,500 gns |
| Clwyd Welsh Pony & Cob Association Autumn Sale, Wales | September 26, 2026 | Top £2,800 (two Section C geldings); Section A filly foal £1,200 |
| Welsh Pony and Cob Society Spring Sale, Brecon | Sunday, May 21 (year not printed) | Average just under £1400; Section A top £1,550 |
Source: Aberdeen and Northern Marts: Lerwick Sale Report; McCartneys: Shetland Pony Sale Report; Clwyd WPCA: Sales; Welsh Pony and Cob Society: Spring Sale Report, checked November 18, 2026.
At Lerwick, 1000 guineas was met or exceeded thirteen times. Worcester had an entry of 370 lots but prints no average. The Brecon average covers ponies and cobs; its £5,900 top lot was a Section D stallion, a cob.
Miniature horses, lessons and cheaper horses
The American Miniature is its own height breed, no more than 34 inches per Oklahoma State University; one breeder, Snuggle Farms, prices its miniatures at $3000-$7000.
Source: Oklahoma State University: Miniature Horses, checked November 18, 2026.
More on how much a mini horse costs.
Riding without buying: see what horse riding lessons cost.
Low-cost horses of any size are covered on the cheapest horse breeds page; all prices start at the home page.
Questions people ask
How much does a real pony cost?
At the Chincoteague auction on July 30, 2026, take-home foals averaged $5,378. One South Carolina seller asks $5,000 to $35,000; rescue fees run from waived to $500.
How much is a mini pony?
Oklahoma State University defines the American Miniature as a height breed of no more than 34 inches. One breeder prices its miniatures at $3000-$7000; see how much a mini horse costs.
How tall is a pony?
Virginia Cooperative Extension’s 4-H guide defines a pony as 14.2 hands or under, which is 58 inches at the withers. Show classes and breed registries set their own limits.